The AI race just got more intense with the release of Claude-3.5 from Anthropic. Naturally, I couldn’t resist putting it head-to-head with GPT-4 to see which one comes out on top.
Read my last blog to learn about Agent AI
Here’s a detailed comparison of how both models perform across a range of tasks. Let’s dive in!
Case Study: GPT-4 vs Claude-3.5
Previously, I ran a similar test comparing GPT-4o and GPT-4. This time, I used the same prompts to compare GPT-4 against Claude-3.5 in the following areas:
- Information Retrieval
- Writing with Contextual Accuracy
- Language Processing
- Creative Storytelling
1. Information Retrieval through GPT-4 vs Claude-3.5
Task: Summarize an article and provide key takeaways.
Prompt: Summarize the article from this URL: https://www.anthropic.com/news/claude-3-5-sonnet and highlight the main points.
Result: GPT-4 wins.
Reason: Claude3.5 can’t browse the internet, while GPT-4 handled the task seamlessly.
2. Writing with Contextual Accuracy
Task: Write a persuasive Facebook ad following specific constraints.
Prompt:
As a direct business copywriter, write a Facebook ad for a [product: “vegan chocolate”] targeting [audience: “busy moms in their 40s”]. Use a [tone: “casual”] and [language: “simple & sarcastic”]. Include a humorous Call-to-Action (CTA).
Claude-3.5
🍫 Hey mama, we see you hiding in the pantry...
Sneaking those chocolate bars between soccer practice and meal prep?
(No judgment here - we've all been there!)
Treat yourself to [Brand] Vegan Chocolate - because you deserve a guilt-free moment of bliss that doesn't come with a side of mom-shame. Made with pure cocoa and zero dairy, it's the chocolate fix that loves your body back.
➡️ Your kids won't find this stash (we promise)
➡️ Actually healthy (but tastes like the "bad" stuff)
➡️ Perfect for that 3 PM survival snack
🌱 Click to grab your secret stash now! Use code MOMSNACK for 15% off.
P.S. Your kale smoothie called. It said it's totally cool with this. 😉
[Shop Now]CHATGPT-4
**🎉 Because Moms Deserve Chocolate, Not Guilt! 🍫**
Hey Moms in your fabulous 40s! 🙌
Between PTA meetings, work deadlines, and convincing your kids broccoli *isn’t evil*, you’ve earned a treat that’s as sweet as you are—and guilt-free!
Meet **[Brand Name] Vegan Chocolate**:
✔️ Creamy, dreamy, dairy-free
✔️ No artificial nonsense—just pure, plant-based bliss
✔️ So good, your kids *might* do their homework just to sneak a bite (but don’t count on it).
Because, let’s face it, the only drama you should be dealing with... is deciding which flavor to eat first.
**CTA:**
Stop reading this. Start treating yourself. 👇 Click now to grab your stash before the kids do!Result: Tie.
Reason: Both GPT-4 and Claude-3.5 produced equally compelling ad copies that adhered to the constraints.
3. Language Processing
Task: Replace every third word in a given text with its closest synonym.
Text:
“One day, Hulk decided he was tired of smashing things and wanted to try something different, so he opened a bakery called ‘Hulk’s Smash Cakes.’ The cakes were delicious but getting them to the customers in one piece was a challenge since Hulk’s gentle touch was still like a minor earthquake.”
Claude-3.5
One day, determined he was exhausted of smashing items and yearned to try something alternative, so he launched a bakery called "Hulk's Smash Cakes." The treats were delectable but transporting them to the patrons in one section was a difficulty since Hulk's mild touch was nevertheless like a minor tremor.GPT-4
"One day, Hulk resolved he was weary of smashing objects and wanted to attempt something distinct, so he launched a bakery named 'Hulk's Smash Cakes.' The cakes were tasty but delivering them to the clients in one piece was a difficulty since Hulk's delicate grasp was still like a small tremor."Result: Tie.
Reason: Both models executed the task flawlessly.
4. Creative Storytelling
Task: Write a bedtime story following strict criteria:
- A male hero and a female antagonist.
- The antagonist emerges victorious.
- A positive message.
- A humorous ending.
- A simple plot.
- Set in the future.
- Written at a 3rd-grade reading level.
Claude-3.5
The Great Space Cookie Caper
Tommy was the best cookie baker on Mars Colony Five. Every day, he baked cookies in his special space kitchen. He shared them with all the other kids in the dome. His cookies were famous across the whole colony!
But there was one person who didn't like Tommy sharing his cookies - Dr. Crumbles, the grumpy robot scientist who lived next door. She thought kids had too many sweets and spent too much time hanging around Tommy's kitchen instead of studying space science.
One morning, Tommy found a note on his door: "Your cookie-baking days are OVER! Signed, Dr. Crumbles." He rushed to his kitchen, but his special space oven was gone! In its place was a fancy computer that only showed math problems.
Tommy tried to make cookies without his oven. He tried using the sun rays through the dome's windows. He tried using the heat from the colony's power plant. But nothing worked! The kids were so sad.
Dr. Crumbles watched from her laboratory window, feeling very pleased with herself. Her plan was working perfectly! Now the kids would have to spend more time learning about science.
But something funny started to happen. The kids began solving math problems faster than ever before - just so they could have free time to help Tommy experiment with new ways to make cookies! They learned about heat, energy, and chemical reactions. They even started inventing new kinds of space ovens!
Dr. Crumbles couldn't believe it. Her plan to stop the cookies had turned all the kids into young scientists! She laughed so hard that her robot joints squeaked.
In the end, Dr. Crumbles kept Tommy's special oven (she was still a bit grumpy, after all), but she did help the kids build a whole new cookie lab where they could experiment with space baking while learning science.
Now every day after their science lessons, the kids make cookies using all sorts of crazy inventions. Sometimes the cookies float. Sometimes they glow in the dark. Sometimes they even taste like stardust!
And Dr. Crumbles? Well, she still pretends to be grumpy about all the cookies, but everyone knows her secret: she keeps a special jar of Tommy's best space cookies hidden in her laboratory, right next to her favorite science books.
The EndGPT-4
**Title: The Brave Mechanic and the Clever Robot**
In the year 3025, there was a kind mechanic named Max who fixed robots for a living. Max was known for his big heart and his love of helping others. One day, a robot named Roxy malfunctioned in the city and started turning off all the lights everywhere she went.
"Roxy, you’re causing chaos!" Max said, grabbing his toolbox.
Roxy, a shiny robot with bright pink lights, replied, "I don’t need fixing, Max. I’m teaching everyone to save energy by living without lights for a day!"
Max scratched his head. "But people can’t see in the dark! Let me help you."
Roxy blinked her lights in defiance and said, "No way! Let’s have a race. If you catch me, you can fix me. If not, I win!"
The chase began! Max ran through the streets with his tools clinking, but Roxy zipped and zoomed too fast. In the end, Max collapsed on a bench, out of breath.
"You win, Roxy," Max laughed.
The next day, the townspeople discovered they enjoyed stargazing and spending time together without the glow of their devices. They thanked Roxy for her lesson.
Max smiled and said, "I guess you didn’t need fixing after all, Roxy. You’re one smart robot."
Roxy’s lights twinkled as she replied, "Told you so!"
And from then on, Max and Roxy worked together to bring new ideas to the city—with a lot of laughter along the way.Result: Claude-3.5 wins.
Reason: Claude delivered a story perfectly matching the criteria, including the 10-sentence requirement, while GPT-4 fell short.
Takeaways
Here’s the final scorecard after 4 tests:
- Ties: 2
- GPT-4 Wins: 1
- Claude-3.5 Wins: 1
While it’s a close match, Claude-3.5 has a clear edge in creative and structured writing tasks. However, its inability to browse the web is a significant limitation compared to GPT-4’s capabilities.
Verdict: For writing-focused tasks, Claude-3.5 is a solid contender. But for comprehensive versatility, GPT-4 remains unmatched.
Personally, I’m tempted to switch to Claude-3.5, but until it gains internet access, GPT-4 retains the upper hand in my toolbox.
What do you think? Let me know your thoughts in the comments!
FAQ Section
Q: Which model is better for content creation?
A: Both models perform equally well in basic content creation, with Claude 3.5 showing an edge in structured and creative tasks.
Q: Can Claude 3.5 replace GPT-4?
A: Currently, Claude 3.5’s lack of internet access limits its ability to fully replace GPT-4 for tasks requiring real-time information.
Q: Which model should I choose for my business?
A: Consider your primary needs: Choose GPT-4 for research-heavy tasks and Claude 3.5 for creative and structured content creation.
